In your own lifetime, you might have noticed the streets you walk down every day changing. New convenience stores pop up; old homes are torn down; restaurants come and go. Historians looking to reconstruct a cityscape from decades or even centuries ago need as much data as possible about what it looked like then. Consider the following photographic records of past cityscapes, then discuss: would they be enough to reconstruct the world as it existed when they were taken? What advice would you give to someone trying to photograph the world we live in today for future reconstruction?

Ed Ruscha | Sunset Boulevard

This is one of the million frames captured for the 12 sunsets project.

This is one of the million frames captured for the 12 sunsets project.

Sébah & Joaillier | Ottoman Panorama

canvas.png

William M. McCarthy | Pre-1906 San Francisco

“Market St. San Francisco -- 1906. Street scene of Market Street in San Francisco before the earthquake and fire of April 1906.” This is one of the several images in the article.

“Market St. San Francisco -- 1906. Street scene of Market Street in San Francisco before the earthquake and fire of April 1906.” This is one of the several images in the article.

Images of the Late Qing Dynasty

Images of Meiji-Era Japan

Explore the Japanese art of kintsugi—the repair of broken pottery using lacquers that do nothing to conceal the original fractures. Practitioners see an object's breakage and repair as an integral part of the object's history. Discuss with your team: should the principles of kintsugi be applied to other forms of reconstructing the past?

Examples of kintsugi.

Examples of kintsugi.

Whether we see Edward Hopper's Nighthawks as a testament to solitude or a bittersweet tug toward a lost era of root beer floats, it has provided rich source material for new takes in both academic art and pop culture. Consider the selections below, then discuss: do works such as Nighthawks oversimplify how we see the past? Can images be too iconic?

Nighthawks | Edward Hopper - In an all-night diner, three customers sit at the counter opposite a server, each appear to be lost in thought and disengaged from one another. The composition is tightly organized and spare in details: there is no entrance to the establishment, no debris on the streets. Through harmonious geometric forms and the glow of the diner’s electric lighting, Hopper created a serene, beautiful, yet enigmatic scene. Although inspired by a restaurant Hopper had seen on Greenwich Avenue in New York, the painting is not a realistic transcription of an actual place. As viewers, we are left to wonder about the figures, their relationships, and this imagined world.

Nighthawks by Edward Hopper

Nighthawks by Edward Hopper

Are You Using that Chair | Banksy

Boulevard of Broken Dreams | Gottfried Helnwein